Search This Blog

Sunday, January 27, 2019

Book Review: Time Travel, a history

Time Travel, by James Gleick is subtitled " A history".  In it, Gleick traces the origins of the idea of "time travel", which did appear in a way as part of some stories from time to time (such as a Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court), but that Wells' Time Machine made it explicit.  Paired with this is that physics, in the early 20th Century now also started investigating the nature of time as "the fourth dimension" of spacetime and that physicists were working on the mathematics to try to see if time travel a la Wells was allowed by Nature.  Gleick takes his cues from literature (mostly science fiction) and physics, launching into detailed discussions of the philosophical ramifications of the ideas.
Clearly from the fact that the chapters usually end in questions, time is something that humanity experiences constantly but it has a slipperiness that evades a good definition.  If somehow one could get outside of time to examine it from a different perspective one could make some sense of what it is.  But even this thought, if someone tries to clarify it, is found to be either so vague as to be meaningless or full of unresolvable paradoxes.  Every consideration regarding backward travel in time ends up into a discussion of determinism vs. free will.  Forward time travel at an increased rate is perfectly acceptable and there is a technical solution: park a space ship close to a black hole for a couple of days and when you head back to civilization, you will find centuries have passed.  So far, it seems that it is a one-way ticket though.
I have a hesitation in recommending this book.  If one has not thought deeply about the subject of time and time travel, there are many naïve thoughts that Gleick destroys, but one gets frustrated because I did not get the sense that something was suggested as backfill.  Further, since I am listening to it as an eAudiobook borrowed from the library, the convolutions created in some of the argumentation that I covered become unclear.  Some of the subtleties are not brought out in the contrast as well as I would have liked.  Nonetheless, there are many rewarding aspects and the book has been deeply researched.  The variety of references and sources, from Wells to Spock, philosophers to physicists, is astounding and surprising in some cases.  If you have thought philosophically about time and time travel and enjoy science fiction, then you will relish this book.  For the average person, it is ahead of its time.

Executive Order 13825: Manual for Courts-Martial

What the Executive Order says

Executive Order (EO) 13825 is entitled "2018 Amendments to the Manual for Courts-Martial, United States" and has 12sections.  It was originally issued in March 2018.

Section 1

This section indicates that the changed versions of Parts II, III and IV of the Manual for Courts-Martial are included as Annex 1 to the EO.

Section 2

This section indicates that for when the change was effective, that you can't be charged with a crime nor have the charges dropped due to a change regarding the deed in the changes made today.

Section 3

This section discusses the Military Justice Act of 2016, which is PL 114-328.  Section 5542 directs the President to prescribe implementing regulations for all of the changes listed in Division E of the Law.

Section 4

So while Annex 1 shows a bunch of changes made, there are further changes in Annex 2.

Section 5

This section indicates that the changes in Annex 2, unlike the changes in Annex 1, take effect in the future.  The language here again indicates that people can't be made guilty or innocent for deeds committed on the opposite side of the effective date.

Sections 6 through 12

These sections makes further clarifications regarding the applicability and interpretation of certain sections of PL 114-328.  It is not clear to me why they had put things into different sections of the EO, especially since the date of effect is January 1, 2019 for almost all of the items listed in these sections.

My Commentary

The preamble, which sets out the authorities on which this EO is issued, indicates that by 10 USC 801, Congress has deemed that the President has the authority to direct and define the justice processes and military law applicable within the military.  Insofar as adjudication of incidents involving both military and civilian participants, it is not clear whether military or civilian law has precedence.  So prior to this, I had been under the false belief that Congress also defines military law, but apparently it does not.  A scan of new articles on the topic, especially since a lot of the changes are going into effect this past month, leaves me with the impression that it is regarding crimes of a sexual nature that are affected the greatest.



Saturday, January 26, 2019

Executive Order 13824: Sports, Fitness, and Nutrition

What the Executive Order Says

Executive Order (EO) 13824 is entitled "President's Council on Sports, Fitness, and Nutrition" (note the Oxford comma) and has 2 sections.  It was issued in February of 2018.

Section 1

This section revokes EO 13545 which the previous President used to establish his "President's Council on Sports, Fitness, and Nutrition."

Section 2

With EO 13545 having been revoked, EO 13265 comes back into force, but this section makes a number of changes to the text of it.  However, technically, the changes listed interfere with each other.  Section 5 is changed by (c), then renumbered by (d) and then further changed by (a) (b) (c) which are under (d).

My commentary

So I characterized this as word soup.  It is so hard to read documents that are created this way.  You have to be able to access the original plus the list of changes and then work through the integration of the changes into the original.  Having pieced together what the final version is, it creates a council and, depending on whether the administration and the council take the charge seriously, it could do some good things or not.
One point made in the purpose section is that team sports participation by children has declined.  I have to ask what is so special about team sports.  I have found these kinds of organized leagues and teams to be expensive and a proportion of the people involved petty and vindictive.  There is the cliché of the one kid who is on the team but never gets to play.  It's a cliché because it does happen even though it really should not.  Physical exercise need not be an organized sport, whether team or individual.  The real justification here should have been statistics about children's and young adult's health.  But talking about that would get into the third rail of "HealthCare" and Republicans simply do not have a defendable alternative to the current system to offer.  But the statistics show there is room for improvement.
Further, this is one of the things that it seems that Presidents use to play one-upmanship games with.  We've seen a couple of these kinds of EO's issued in our review.  Here, EO 13824 revokes EO 13545 which itself largely modified EO 13265 which itself revokes EO 12345.  The President's council can be reviewed here.

Wednesday, January 23, 2019

Executive Order 13823: Terrorists

What the Executive Order says

Executive Order (EO) 13823 is entitled "Protecting America Through Lawful Detention of Terrorists." and has 4 sections.  It was issued in January 2018.

Section 1

This section starts awkwardly citing "long-standing law of war principles" which I guess is trying to reference the Geneva Convention. This section is subtitled "Findings" and tries to present a justification as to why the US can detain persons considered enemies of the US at the Guantanamo Bay Naval Station.

Section 2

This section revokes Section 3 of EO 13492.  That EO and that specific section called for the closure of the detention facilities at Guantanamo by January of 2010.  Clearly, that never happened.  Section 2(c) allows for transport of additional detainees to Guantanamo.  Section 2(d) has several layers of irony in asking for a report from the intelligence agency to recommend policies on prisoners of war and the use of the Guantanamo Bay Detention facility.  First, because the EO's seem to always look for a report to be written, second because there are news stories and books published detailing how the current President does not listen to the Intelligence Services anyway.  The last subsection references EO 13567 from March of 2011.  That EO set up a review process for period reviews of detainee files to expedite a final disposition so that detainees could be all removed from Guantanamo.  Subsection 2(e) of EO 13823 stipulates that any new detainees would be subject to the same periodic reviews.

Section 3

This section adds some language that restricts the applicability to those persons captured during an armed conflict, and in the case they are American citizens, that this does not deprive the detainees of their rights as citizens.

Section 4

This section includes language to limit the applicability such that is does not conflict with applicable laws or create any legal liabilities against the US Government.

My commentary

The most significant item in this EO is 2(a) wherein section 3 of EO 13492 is revoked.  That section had mandated that the authorities work to remove all the prisoners held at Guantanamo Bay Naval Base and close the detention facility.  As such, the detention facility is to be used in an ongoing fashion to detain existing and new detainees as necessary.  The EO is fairly symbolic as it stakes out the administrations attitude towards prisoners of war and other individuals considered "enemies of the US" (except, of course, journalists).
The funny thing about life to me is that when you go looking for something, more often than not, you seem to find it.  Thus the way to find good things in life is to go looking for those good things.  If the US spends a lot of resources looking for enemies, she shall certainly find them.  And here is the stark contrast between the erstwhile and present administrations: one looked for friends, the other for enemies.  Hence the 180 degree shift in policy from emptying the detention facility at Guantanamo to using it for more found enemies.

Sunday, January 20, 2019

Executive Order 13822:Supporting Veterans

What the Executive Order Says

Executive Order (EO) 13822 is entitled "Supporting our veterans during their transition from uniformed service to civilian life" and it has 3 sections.  This EO was issued in January 2018.

Section 1

This section defines the policy which is that veterans need better access to mental healthcare services including suicide prevention resources.

Section 2

This section has 3 subsections.  (a) directs the Secretary of Defense, Secretary of Veterans Affairs and the Secretary of Homeland security to do something.  Doesn't really say what they should do.  (b) mandates that the group mentioned need to submit within 60 days a Joint Action Plan.  (c) mandates that a follow-up report on the progress of implementation of the Joint Action Plan be issued within 180 days.

Section 3

This section includes general provisions that limit the authority of the EO to ensure that it does not overstep legislative and constitutional limits.

My Commentary

I have looked on the internet for the Joint Action Plan and follow-up report since due to the age of this EO, it clearly should be available.  On the Veterans Affairs website, I found this updated action plan.  This plan defines 16 actions to be implemented that will support the reduction in suicides and mental health incidents for veterans.  I found this status update report dated July 9, 2018 although it is watermarked "DRAFT".  I would like to think that this had made a difference in at least some veteran's lives.  But it is not clear that there has been much success and since there does not seem to be any mandated report to follow up the implementations (while most of the 16 actions were "On track", none were expected to be completed until mid-2019), we may never know.

Saturday, January 19, 2019

Executive Order 13821: Rural Broadband Internet

What the Executive Order Says

Executive Order (EO) 13821 is entitled "Streamlining and Expediting Requests to Locate Broadband Facilities in Rural America".  It has 4 sections and was originally issued in January of 2018.

Section 1

This section defines the policy.  It first states that internet access is rural areas is a problem that can be an obstruction to growth, development, and jobs.  The actions being taken are indicated as aiming for regulatory reform and reduction.  The last paragraph indicates that continued implementation of section 6409 of PL 112-96 shall be pursued.

Section 2

This section has 5 different subsections.  The Administrator of General Services is directed to make a review of the common form application and based on the review, due in July of 2018, make changes to the form.  (c) directs various bureaucrats to review and approve requests to mount antennas on Federal Property. (d) and (e) mandate that quarterly reporting is generated on the application process.

Section 3

This section includes definitions for the terms "Federal property managing agencies" and "Federal real property".

Section 4

This section contains general provisions that limit the authority of the Executive Order so as not to appear to override existing laws or create any liabilities for the US Federal Government.

My commentary

So overall, this policy amplifies a policy that was created by a previous congress and simply creates some reporting requirements around it.  Now the GSA has to report the number of applications that were received to mount microwave band antennas on the roofs of federal buildings.  I have not been able to find these reports anywhere.  How exactly this helps get broadband to everyday rural citizens is a bit mysterious to me.  I don't think this EO was terribly effective to change anything.
There are some political ironies in the issue of this EO.  First, the current administration is highlighting and endorsing a policy that was created under the previous administration.  The current administration has been strongly pushing for elimination and relaxation of regulations and why this seems only to be a step sideways instead of in the direction of elimination is unclear to me.
I can see that cell towers and similar communications array facilities are subject to the NIMBY effect where everyone wants these to be built, but just not on, beside or near their particular home or business.  The 112th congress seemed to have it right in mandating that it be allowed to have such communication arrays put on federal land when necessary due to local resistance to siting.  One of the sub-texts here is that siting requests that are being held up on environmental impact or other such concerns are the culprit.  Of course there is only a limited amount of space on federal land and the federal government needs to hold some in reserve for future internal needs.  As such, I suspect that the agencies where there have been proposals have jealously guarded the capacity.
In terms of implementation, I have found little to support that any real action happened after the issue of the EO.  However, this FCC report seems to echo a number of the concerns listed in the EO about the slowness of the process for siting approvals.  This topic has been discussed often and for quite some time.  One opinion piece that I found attributed the slowness of rural broadband expansion to the FCC dragging their feet on any number of regulatory or permitting issues.  This EO was just preceded by a memo to the Secretary of the Interior.  I think that the issue and vacuous nature of the memo and EO point to policy arguments within the administration.  Expanding broadband internet may not be appealing to the free market (well, really it is an oligopoly) and I feel that some government intervention in the market is warranted.

Thursday, January 17, 2019

Executive Order 13820: Termination of Election Integrity Commission

What the Executive Order says

Executive Order (EO) 13820 is entitled "Termination of Presidential Advisory Commission on Election Integrity" and has 2 sections.  It was originally issued in January of 2018.

Section 1

This section revokes EO 13799 from May of 2017.

Section 2

This section includes the standard fine print asserting the constitutionality of the EO.

My Commentary

Well, after a lot of controversy, the commission on Election Integrity, which was intended to try and prove that 3 -5 million fraudulent votes had been cast in favor of the Democratic nominee such that the President had won the popular vote, was shut down.
With respect to the politics of the situation, it was really quite a serious embarrassment for the Republican party, but it was necessary since the commission had been repudiated and it had become clear that it was established on a lie.  See my commentary here.